C/D378 (SBI)


C/D 378 Ecumenical and Interfaith Dialogue
St. Bernard’s School of Theology and Ministry, Spring 2006
Instructor: Dennis E. Tamburello, O.F.M., Ph.D.


Home phone: (518) 783-4175
Office phone: (518) 783-2924
E-mail: tamburello@siena.edu

Course Outline
Selected Bibliography

Instructions for Reflective Essay

A. Course Description:

This course will examine the Roman Catholic church’s involvement in ecumenical and interfaith dialogue since the time of the Second Vatican Council (1962-65). It will include discussion of the historical context of the dialogue, some of the major primary documents related to it, and the theological and ecclesiological issues that have shaped it. The course will take a critical look at both the successes and the tensions that have accompanied the dialogue, from both theological and institutional perspectives.

The goals of this course are to enable the student: (1) to understand the historical and theological grounds for ecumenical and interfaith dialogue; (2) to analyze critically the common ground Catholicism shares with other traditions, and to identify the areas of difference or disagreement that exist; (3) to appreciate and respect the integrity of other religious traditions, and to be open to learning from them, while remaining firmly committed to one’s own tradition.

B.  Style and method:

The course will be taught in a lecture and discussion format. The methodology employed will be text- and historical-critical.

C. Required Readings:

The following books are required for the course:

Wayne Teasdale, Catholicism in Dialogue: Conversations Across Traditions. New York: Rowman and Littlefield, 2004.

James L. Fredericks. Faith Among Faiths: Christian Theology and Non-Christian Religions. New York: Paulist Press, 1999.

Lutheran World Federation and the Roman Catholic Church. Joint Declaration on the Doctrine of Justification. Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 2000. (Text also available online at the Vatican website.)

United States Conference of Catholic Bishops. The Bible, the Jews, and the Death of Jesus. Washington: USCCB Publications, 2004.

Additional readings will be posted online or given as handouts. I will take care of any necessary copyright permissions, and will ask the class to reimburse me for any fees.

D. Papers:

Each student is asked to submit a 10-15 page research paper on a specific theological or ecclesial issue in ecumenical or interfaith dialogue. Students should select a topic that expands on or complements, rather than duplicates, materials covered in the class sessions. The paper must have a thesis and be referenced according to Chicago (preferred—with either footnotes or endnotes) or MLA standards. The due date of the paper is to be negotiated by each student with the instructor. It must be no later than a week after the last class, so that I can submit grades in a timely fashion.

In addition, students will be asked to prepare one summary/discussion guide on a required reading for the class, as well as one reflective essay (out of a choice of six) of 3-5 pages.

Grades:

Grades will be computed according to the following percentages: Research Paper 40%, Reflective essay 30%, Discussion guide 10%, Overall Participation 20%.

Course Outline: 

Jan. 4

Introduction to the Course: Review of Syllabus
Background to the Dialogue
Required Reading: Teasdale, Part I, pp. 3-37
 

Jan. 11

Ground Rules for Dialogue
Foundational Catholic Documents on Ecumenism
Required Reading: Leonard Swidler, “The Dialogue Decalogue” (distributed)
                                  Vatican II Decree on Ecumenism
                                  Teasdale, Part II, pp. 41-80
 

Jan. 18

The Lutheran-Catholic Dialogue I
Required Reading: Joint Declaration on the Doctrine of Justification
 

Jan. 25

The Lutheran-Catholic Dialogue II
Discussion with Dr. Tom Dickens, Dept. of Religious Studies, Siena College
Required Reading: “Joint Declaration on Justification: Reformed Comments” by
                                  Anna Case-Winters. From Concord Makes Strength (distributed)
 

Feb. 1

The Reformed-Catholic Dialogue I
Discussion with Rev. John Paarlberg, First Church of Albany
Required Reading: “Ecumenism in Reformed Perspective” by Karel Blei.
                                  from Concord Makes Strength” (distributed)
                                 The Presence of Christ in Church and World” (online)
 

Feb. 8

The Reformed-Catholic Dialogue II
Required Reading: “Towards a Common Understanding of Church” (online)
                                  “Christ at the Center” by D. Tamburello (online pdf file)
 

Feb. 15

Other Ecumenical Dialogues/Issues
Required Reading: Joint Catholic-Orthodox Declaration, 1965
                                  2004 Report of the International Joint Commission
                                  Baptism and "Sacramental Economy"
Recommended Reading: Other Orthodox-Roman Catholic documents
 

Feb. 22

Issues in Interfaith Dialogue I: The Rise of Pluralism
Foundational Catholic Documents
Required Reading: Fredericks, Chapters 1-4, pp. 1-99
                                  Vatican II “Declaration on the Relation of the Church to Non-Christian Religions”
 

Mar. 1

 

Dialogue with the Jews
Required Reading: The Bible, the Jews, and the Death of Jesus (selected documents)
                                  “A Sacred Obligation” from the Christian Scholars Group
A helpful resource: Boston College's Center for Christian-Jewish Learning
A helpful resource on Nostra Aetate: Anti-Defamation League website
 

Mar. 8

 

Dialogue with Islam
Required Reading: Vatican Council and Papal Statements on Islam
                                  Catholic-Muslim Relations in the United States
 

Mar. 15

No class
 

Mar. 22

 

Dialogue with Eastern Religions
Required Reading: The Los Angeles Buddhist-Catholic Dialogue

                                             God and Buddhism - An essay by John Cobb
                                  "Jesus the Christ and Shakyamuni Buddha" - from The Buddha and the Christ (distributed)
                                  Towards One World Family -  address from the Hindu-Christian consultation
 

Mar. 29

 

Issues in Interfaith Dialogue II: Pitfalls and Possibilities for Catholicism
Required Reading: Teasdale, Part III, Chapters 7-8; Part IV
                                  Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith, “Dominus Iesus”
                                  Dominus Iesus: A Stumbling Block to Reformed-Catholic Dialogue?” (distributed)
 

Apr. 5

Issues in Interfaith Dialogue II: Evaluating Pluralism
Summary and Conclusions
Required Reading: Fredericks, Chapters 5-8, pp. 103-180
 

Apr. 12

Snow date

 Back to Fr. Dennis Tamburello's home page