Siena Research Institute

Siena College, Loudonville, NY

www.siena.edu/sri

 

For Immediate Release:                        Monday, April 11, 2005

Contact:                                               Joe Caruso at 518-783-2901

PDF version (with crosstabs):             

 

Siena New York Poll:

 

Majority of NYers Say They Have A Health Care Proxy

 

Gov’s Favorability Rebounds; Still Loses to Spitzer

 

Giuliani Beats Spitzer; Loses to Hillary

 

NYers Divide Credit for On-time Budget Among

Governor, Senate, Assembly, Public

 

Loudonville, NY – More than half of New Yorkers – including 62 percent of those over 55 years old – claim to have a health care proxy, designating someone to make medical decision for them if they are unable to do so.  Nearly two-thirds of those who don’t have one say the Terri Schiavo case makes them more likely to complete a health care proxy, according to a new Siena (College) Research Institute poll of New York voters released today.

 

“More than half of New Yorkers say they already have a health care proxy.  And it is encouraging that the tragic events surrounding the Terri Schiavo case in Florida will move many New Yorkers who have not completed a health care proxy to do so,” said Joe Caruso, Director of Polling for the Siena Research Institute (SRI).

 

Governor George Pataki’s favorability rating rose dramatically in the last month (50 percent favorable to 39 percent unfavorable), up from 37-50 percent a month ago.  And while only 29 percent of New York voters say they will vote to re-elect him (55 percent would prefer someone else), similar to results the last two months, he has narrowed his gap in a head-to-head match up with Attorney General Eliot Spitzer.  Spitzer leads 48 percent to 34 percent, a 14-point lead, down from last month’s 23-point lead.

 

“George Pataki has made up ground with voters in virtually every part of the state and in every demographic group,” Caruso said. “But if he chooses to run for re-election, he is still in an uncomfortable position for an incumbent, given his continued low ‘re-elect number.’ 

 

“While voters don’t give him more credit for the on-time budget than they give either house of the Legislature, he seems to have gotten a bounce from the widespread media attention to the state’s first on-time budget in 21 years.  However, he still significantly trails Spitzer in a head-to-head match up,” Caruso said.

 

– more –

 

Siena New York Poll

Monday, April 11, 2005

Page 2 of 2

 

When asked who deserves the most credit for the state’s on-time budget, voters are split, with the Governor, Senate and Assembly all receiving approximately the same credit (16, 15, 14 percent, respectively).  Nearly as many, 11 percent, give the public credit for creating the pressure.  Five percent credit the Governor and Legislature equally.

 

“While the Governor, Senate and Assembly have all claimed credit for making an on-time budget happen, voters are almost as likely to give themselves credit as they are to give their elected officials a pat on the back,” Caruso said.

 

Since last month, Spitzer’s favorable rating inched up to 53-18 percent (up from 50-18 percent), as did Senator Hillary Clinton’s – up to 60-33 percent (from 58-34 percent).  Similarly, former New York City Mayor Rudolph Giuliani’s favorability rating was 63-26 percent, slightly higher than two months ago (61-28 percent). 

 

Giuliani slightly increased his lead over Spitzer in a gubernatorial match up to 50-38 percent in the last two months (from 49-40 percent).  However, Clinton similarly increased her lead over Giuliani in a potential Senate match up 52-41 percent (from 52-43 percent).

 

“Rudy Giuliani remains a strong political force in New York – should he choose to seek election in the state rather than at the national level.  He has the support of half of New Yorkers in a race against Spitzer.  At the same time, more than half of New York voters would reject Rudy, in favor of Hillary if he decides to challenge her next year,” Caruso said.

 

New York voters see “improving education” (24 percent) as the most important issue for state government to address, beating out “improving health care” (22 percent) and “creating new jobs” (16 percent).  Less important were “reforming state government” (10 percent), “fighting crime” (5 percent) and “protecting the environment” (3 percent).  These results have not changed dramatically in the last month.

 

“New York voters continue to be very pessimistic about the direction of the state. Only 29 percent believe New York is on the right track, while 44 percent believe the state is headed in the wrong direction,” Caruso said.

 

The Empire Page, in partnership with the Siena Research Institute, will release the results of two questions concerning the use of public support for sports stadiums tomorrow.

 

This SRI survey was conducted April 3-7, 2005 by telephone calls to 582 New York State registered voters.  It has a margin of error of + 4.1 points.  For more information or comments, please call Joe Caruso, SRI Director of Polling, at 518-783-2901.  Survey cross-tabulations and frequencies can be found at www.siena.edu/sri/surveys.asp. 

 

# # #

 

 

 

 

 

Siena Research Institute

Siena College, Loudonville, NY

www.siena.edu/sri

 

Siena New York Poll Trends

 

If George Pataki runs for Governor in 2006, would you vote to re-elect him or would you prefer someone else?

 

            Date                              Re-Elect      Prefer Someone Else   Don’t Know/No Opinion

            April, 2005                            29                          55                                   17

            March, 2005                         24                          60                                   16

February, 2005                     27                          57                                   16

 

If the election for Governor were held tomorrow and the candidates were George Pataki on the Republican line and Eliot Spitzer on the Democratic line, for whom would you vote? (Rotate choices)

 

            Date                                 Pataki                  Spitzer              Don’t Know/No Opinion

            April, 2005                            34                          48                                   18

            March, 2005                         30                          53                                   17

February, 2005                     35                          51                                   15

 

If the election for Governor were held tomorrow and the candidates were Rudolph Giuliani on the Republican line and Eliot Spitzer on the Democratic line, for whom would you vote? (Rotate choices)

 

            Date                               Giuliani                 Spitzer              Don’t Know/No Opinion

            April, 2005                            50                          38                                   11

February, 2005                     49                          40                                   11

 

If the election for U.S. Senate were held tomorrow and the candidates were Hillary Clinton on the Democratic line and Rudolph Giuliani on the Republican line, for whom would you vote? (Rotate choices)

 

            Date                                Clinton               Giuliani             Don’t Know/No Opinion

            April, 2005                            52                          41                                   8

February, 2005                     52                          43                                   5

 

Do you have a favorable or unfavorable opinion about George Pataki?

 

            Date                            Favorable           Unfavorable        Don’t Know/No Opinion

            April, 2005                            50                          39                                   11

            March, 2005                         37                          50                                   13

February, 2005                     39                          45                                   16

 

Do you have a favorable or unfavorable opinion about Eliot Spitzer?

 

            Date                            Favorable           Unfavorable        Don’t Know/No Opinion

            April, 2005                            53                          18                                   29

            March, 2005                         50                          18                                   32

February, 2005                     48                          17                                   34

 

 

 

Siena New York Poll Trends, Page 2

 

Do you have a favorable or unfavorable opinion about Hillary Clinton?

 

            Date                            Favorable           Unfavorable        Don’t Know/No Opinion

            April, 2005                            60                          33                                   6

            March, 2005                         58                          34                                   8

February, 2005                     61                          33                                   6

 

Do you have a favorable or unfavorable opinion about Rudolph Giuliani?

 

            Date                            Favorable           Unfavorable        Don’t Know/No Opinion

            April, 2005                            63                          26                                   10

February, 2005                     61                          28                                   11

 

Is New York State on the right track, or is it headed in the wrong direction?

 

            Date                            Right Track    Wrong Direction   Don’t Know/No Opinion

            April, 2005                            29                          44                                   27

            March, 2005                         26                          47                                   27

February, 2005                     32                          44                                   24

 

What is the single most important issue New York State government should address in 2005? (Rotate choices)

 

                                                Fighting         Improving        Protecting                 Improving  

Date                               Crime           Education      Environment             Health Care

            April, 2005                         5                         24                    3                                  22

            March, 2005                      3                         24                    3                                  18

 

                                                Creating        Reforming          Passing                                       

Date                            New Jobs        State Govt.   State Budget        Other        DK/NO

            April, 2005                         16                       10                    N/A                 18                2

            March, 2005                      14                       6                      11                    17                3